Fire safety measures risk leaving some trapped in their own homes

Urgent action called for as system prioritises fire safety over accessibility, say experts

hand on fire door

Fire safety measures in housing, while designed to protect inhabitants, are leaving older and disabled people trapped in their own homes, according to housing experts. 

Fire safety is happening at the expense of accessibility, with heavy, self-closing fire doors creating daily barriers and sometimes injuries for people with mobility issues, according to a report from the University of Stirling. 

This Bonfire Night, the experts behind the report warn that regulations around fire safety and housing are complex and sometimes conflicting. They call for an overhaul in the system and argue that residents’ voices should be at the heart of that. 

Providing inaccessible fire doors are a clear example of disabling by design, says the report, with older and disabled people, who might have reduced strength, mobility issues or mobility aids, struggling to open self-closing doors. 

Practically challenging

While technical adaptations such as automatic door openers exist, the report highlights that these are often expensive, difficult to fund, and practically challenging to deliver without compromising fire safety certification. Some residents then reject these adaptations altogether, preferring to wedge doors open rather than being trapped, despite the fire risk. 

The report draws on interviews with 12 housing and health practitioners across Scotland, and is informed by data gathered from over 140 community peer-researchers who are older and/or disabled from across the UK. It is part of a wider programme of work examining the stigma attached to age, disability and where people live called the Intersectional Stigma of Place-Based Ageing (ISPA) project 

The report, a collaboration with the Housing Learning and Improvement Network (Housing LIN), says better training and education is needed across housing, health and design professionals, including awareness of the Equality Act 2010.

Photograph of Dr Kim McKee
Professor Kim McKee
Professor of Housing & Social Policy
We know fire safety is vital - but it can’t come at the cost of people’s independence. We urgently need national guidance that brings together housing, health and fire safety professionals to develop solutions that comply with both fire regulations and the Equality Act 2010.

Professor Vikki McCall, Professor of Social Policy at the University of Stirling, said: “We all learned lessons from the horrors of the Grenfell Tower fire of 2017, and the stronger focus on fire safety within building regulations is welcome. However, the residents and practitioners we talked to - from housing association staff to architects to occupational therapists - say some of these new measures, in particular fire doors, risk creating even more disabling environments.  

“For wheelchair users and older people experiencing reduced strength and mobility, simply opening their front door can be exhausting, unsafe, or impossible.” 

Seventy-two people died after a fire broke out in the 4-storey Grenfell Tower block of flats in West London in 2017. The UK and Scottish governments have committed to meeting the recommendations of a report into the disaster, published last year. 

User-centred approach

Professor Kim McKee, Professor of Housing and Social Policy at the University of Stirling, said: “We know fire safety is vital - but it can’t come at the cost of people’s independence. We urgently need national guidance that brings together housing, health and fire safety professionals to develop solutions that comply with both fire regulations and the Equality Act 2010. A more collaborative, empathetic, and user-centred approach to housing design is essential.” 

The full report is available on Housing LIN’s website. Hear more detail from the event hosted by Housing LIN on the topic here. 

ISPA, funded by the Economic and Social Research Council, is a collaboration involving the University of Stirling, Housing LIN, Newcastle University, Scottish Federation of Housing Associations, University of Bristol and University of St Andrews. Find out more here,

UN Sustainable development goals

The University of Stirling is ranked among the top 200 institutions in the world for its contribution to meeting the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). The research or activity detailed above relates to the following SDGs.