Biometrics Commissioner and University Professor calls for more detail on plans to regulate facial recognition use

Professor William Webster welcomes plans for new oversight body, but warns technology is evolving rapidly

crowd of commuters with facial recognition interface
The use and potential use of live facial recognition technologies have attracted criticism from civil liberties groups.

The Biometrics and Surveillance Camera Commissioner, the University of Stirling’s Professor William Webster, has called for more detail on UK Government plans to regulate the use of facial recognition and biometrics.

Professor Webster backed the UK Government's plans for a new oversight body to regulate law enforcement use of the technologies.

However, he said there were key areas that needed to be addressed, including more detail on compliance, resourcing, and coordination with other regulators. He also said oversight must be "robust" and "future-proofed", because technology is evolving rapidly.

Both a new legal framework and the establishment of an independent body were announced last week by the UK Government. The new legislation will establish clear statutory powers and safeguards covering the use of facial recognition, biometrics and related technologies by police and other public bodies, and is the result of a consultation that garnered nearly 14,000 submissions.

In a statement issued today, Professor Webster said: "Whilst the Government's response to the consultation signals a clear direction of travel, which I am very supportive of, it lacks detail in a number of key areas. 

"Facial recognition is likely to become increasingly integrated into existing camera networks, and into body-worn video and drones. The framework must keep pace with these developments while maintaining meaningful oversight and public confidence."

man with glasses
Professor William Webster
Biometrics and Surveillance Camera Commissioner
Facial recognition is likely to become increasingly integrated into existing camera networks, and into body-worn video and drones. The framework must keep pace with these developments while maintaining meaningful oversight and public confidence.

Facial recognition technologies and biometrics are a key area of research for the University of Stirling and Professor Webster, who founded the Centre for Research into Information, Surveillance and Privacy (CRISP).

The use of facial recognition and biometrics technologies in identifying and locating criminals – from doorbells and CCTV in shops, to cameras mounted on police vehicles – is spreading fast, and many consider that their regulation is fragmented.

An estimated 13 police forces in England and Wales have or use live facial recognition (LFR), which uses real-time video feed to biometrically scan faces. LFR is also used by Immigration Enforcement. Police Scotland has confirmed its intention to introduce the technologies. Their use and potential use have attracted criticism from civil liberties groups, and there have been cases of misidentification and claims of racial bias since the technologies were introduced.

The University of Stirling recently announced its involvement in Face[REC], co-led by Stirling criminologist Dr Diana Miranda and funded by The Scottish Institute for Policing Research (SIPR), a research project which focuses on the ethics and regulation of using LFR technologies to fight crime. 

Professor Webster stepped back from academia to take up the two-year role of Biometrics and Surveillance Camera Commissioner for England and Wales in November 2025.